HurricaneLaw.Pro, Florida and South Carolina property insurance claim resource HURRICANELAW.PRO
HOME / DENIALS / THE DOCUMENTS / CITIZENS PROPERTY INSURANCE CORPORATION
DENIAL LANGUAGE QUOTED IN AN APPELLATE OPINION

Citizens: insufficient evidence plus late notice, the double-barrel letter

UPDATED 2026-08-21 FL NOT LEGAL ADVICE
WHAT THIS DOCUMENT IS

This is an appellate court’s written opinion, which quotes the insurer’s denial language while deciding the case. It is the court’s account, not the letter.

Read the opinion

Opens the public record this page is built from, on the source's own site.

REPRESENTATIVE FOOTAGE · MATCHED TO THE ARGUMENT, NOT THE CLAIM
WHAT YOU ARE LOOKING AT

This is a court’s written decision. The judges had the claim file in front of them, and where they quote the insurer’s denial language, that quotation is part of the official record of the case.

Everything quoted below is read off that document. The reading of what it means for each side is ours, and it is marked as such.

01WHO, WHAT, WHERE, WHEN, WHY
Case Bouchard v. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
Court Florida Third District Court of Appeal
Citation No. 3D23-2202
Decided February 19, 2025
Who is involved A Key West homeowner and Citizens, Florida's state-backed insurer of last resort.
What happened Citizens denied the claim for late notice. The trial court granted Citizens summary judgment, and the Third DCA affirmed.
Where Key West, Monroe County, Florida
When Loss November 8, 2020 (Tropical Storm Eta). Proof of loss submitted December 22, 2021, over 13 months later. Denied February 15, 2022.
Why it came out that way Florida law presumes an insurer is prejudiced by late notice. The presumption can be rebutted, and the homeowner did not rebut it.
The holding Affirmed for Citizens.
02WHAT THE DOCUMENT SAYS, VERBATIM
THE DENIAL, QUOTED BY THE COURT
Based on all of the information gathered to date, there is insufficient evidence to substantiate a loss related to Wind - TS ETA on 11/08/2020. Citizens' ability to evaluate this claim has been prejudiced due to failure to report this loss in a timely manner
WHY THE HOMEOWNER WAITED
it's almost how long it took my divorce, and I didn't want to make a claim on the home when I didn't know if it was going to be my home
03WHAT IT MEANS TO EACH SIDE

Our reading of the document above, not the court's words.

For the insurance company

Late notice is the cheapest defense an insurer has, because it does not require any argument about the damage. Once notice is late enough, Florida hands the insurer a presumption of prejudice and the burden flips entirely onto the policyholder.

For the homeowner

The reason for the delay was real and sympathetic, and it made no difference. The court needed evidence that the delay did not harm the investigation, not an explanation of why the delay happened.

04WHAT TO TAKE FROM IT
  1. 1 Report the loss when you see the damage, not when your life settles down. This homeowner saw leaks during the storm.
  2. 2 If notice is already late, the fight is prejudice, not excuse. Preserve anything that shows the insurer could still investigate: photos from the time, unrepaired conditions, contractor records.
  3. 3 Florida now sets the deadline by statute at 1 year for notice and 18 months for a supplemental claim (Fla. Stat. 627.70132).

Bouchard v. Citizens Prop. Ins. Corp., No. 3D23-2202 (Fla. 3d DCA Feb. 19, 2025) Read the document ↗

Case summaries are written from the opinion; read the opinion and check the current docket before relying on any of it. Not legal advice; consult an attorney about your specific claim.

07WHY THIS ONE IS IN THE ARCHIVE

The Third DCA block-quoted this Citizens letter in full, which makes it one of the cleanest specimens in the library: two independent grounds in two sentences, insufficient evidence of a storm loss, and prejudice from late reporting. Either one alone can carry a denial; together they force the policyholder to win twice.

The homeowner reported the Key West wind loss 13.5 months after Tropical Storm Eta, and Florida law did the rest: untimely notice creates a rebuttable presumption that the carrier was prejudiced, and the court found the policyholder’s engineer affidavit too conclusory to rebut it. The lesson is procedural and unforgiving. Late reporting hands the carrier a defense that has nothing to do with what the wind actually did, and generic expert language cannot buy it back; only specific, dated, address-level evidence can. Report first, argue later.

ANSWER THIS ARGUMENT

IN THE RECORD

SOURCE

Bouchard v. Citizens Prop. Ins. Corp., No. 3D23-2202 (Fla. 3d DCA Feb. 19, 2025) · public record ↗

Quotes are verbatim from the cited public record, checked word for word before publication. Case status and statute summaries are as of August 2026; check the current docket and statute. Not legal advice; consult an attorney about your specific claim.

02 · FREE CASE REVIEW

Got a letter like this one?

Upload it. You'll get a straight answer on which argument the carrier is running, how the same argument has fared on the record, and what the strongest next move is.

The library grows one letter at a time. Letters shared with permission are published redacted, with the policyholder's details removed.

CASE FILE · HL-2026 · INTAKE OPEN
FREE CASE REVIEW
PROPERTY INSURANCE CLAIM
ADVERTISEMENT · HALVERSEN LAW

Advertisement paid for by Halversen Law, LLC. Halversen Law reviews your submission. HurricaneLaw.Pro only transmits it.

01Who you are
02Your claim
03Your documents
⇪
Drop your documents here, or tap to browse
Denial letter · policy · adjuster estimate · damage photos, PDF, JPG, PNG, HEIC or DOC, up to 25MB each