HurricaneLaw.Pro, Florida and South Carolina property insurance claim resource HURRICANELAW.PRO
HOME / DENIALS / THE ARCHIVE / CASTLE KEY INDEMNITY
44 FILINGS IN THE ARCHIVE

Castle Key Indemnity: the denial record

44 of the 1,891 Florida property claim-denial filings we read name this insurer. Here is what those filings describe and where to read each one.

How many Florida claim-denial filings name Castle Key Indemnity?

44 of the 1,891 Civil Remedy Notices over denied Florida property claims name Castle Key Indemnity. 5 were later withdrawn or recorded as resolved, which is what the record shows when a carrier fixes the problem inside the 60-day window. Counts follow book size as much as behaviour: a carrier with more Florida policies collects more filings.

Filings naming this insurer 44 of 1,891
Median repair figure named $62,149
Later withdrawn or resolved 5
Most common allegation The claim that never gets decided (34)
What these are Allegations by policyholders, not findings by a court
01WHAT THESE FILINGS DESCRIBE
The claim that never gets decided 34 The estimate that comes in low 21 The decision made without a real look 17 Storm damage called age 13 The retained engineer 10
02EVERY FILING, LARGEST FIGURE FIRST
Castle Key Indemnity Perry Hurricane and wind 12/17/2024 $277,275

FAIRWINDS CONSTRUCTION SERVICES ESTIMATED THE DAMAGE TO THE INSURED'S PROPERTY AT $277,275.89 (RCV)/$269,865.27 (ACV).

Castle Key Indemnity Delray Beach 10/28/2024 $233,527

Subsequently, the insureds prepared a loss package in the amount of $233,527.26 needed to restore the property back to its pre-loss condition, plus weekly rental ALE expenses of $2,450.00 since the date of loss on September 26, 2024.

Castle Key Indemnity Beverly Hills Mold 10/29/2024 $199,910

Then in a letter dated October 5th, 2023 the carrier notified the Insured that it had completed its investigation into the loss and denied the claim.

Castle Key Indemnity Orlando Hurricane and wind 11/15/2024 $197,681

After reporting the claim, Castle Key retained an unqualified and biased field adjuster who has a financial relationship with Castle Key.

Castle Key Indemnity Miami Beach Hurricane and wind 10/11/2024 $172,500

Please advise." Finally, on September 30, 2024, Mr. [name redacted] responded and stated, "The final determination letter is our estimate sent out." Castle Key never provided the Insureds with any further communication or explanation to support their effective denial of $121,801.17 of the Insureds'

Castle Key Indemnity Saint Cloud Hurricane and wind 11/1/2024 $140,491

Based on the insufficient adjustment of the claim as outlined herein, Castle Key on or about July 3, 2022, issued a wholly unsatisfactory valuations of $807.05, which did not exceed the deductible of $1,000.00.

Castle Key Indemnity Wellington Hurricane and wind 1/6/2025 $118,031

After assessing the damage and the true scope of repairs, the public adjuster produced an estimate identifying $118,031.80 in covered damage to the dwelling.

Castle Key Indemnity Lutz Hurricane and wind 1/7/2025 $95,428

The total actual cash value (ACV) value of Castle Key's estimate is $18,179.99 under Coverage A, and $882.89 O&L.

Castle Key Indemnity Weeki Wachee Hurricane and wind 12/23/2024 $84,928

The insured has been compelled to obtain an independently adjusted estimate totaling in the amount of $84,928.64 that would be needed to repair the property back to its pre-loss condition.

Castle Key Indemnity Ocala Hurricane and wind 10/4/2024 $73,943

CASTLE KEY INDEMNITY COMPANY, through its adjustment of the loss, submitted an estimate to the Insured which allegedly represented the actual cash value of the loss pursuant to the Policy Language, however the insurance company determined that the damage did not exceed the applicable deductible.

Castle Key Indemnity Kindred Water damage 2/10/2025 $68,210

Restoration Control also took a plethora of photographs of the property before, during and after its services, and prepared an estimate of damages to put the property back into its pre-loss condition in the amount of $68,210.78.

Castle Key Indemnity Weston Hurricane and wind 10/4/2024 $68,000

To begin, prior to KEE's inspection, as per the contractual obligations imposed by Castle Key, the Insured retained a water mitigation company, who detected the presence of moisture with the affected bedroom and then tarped the roofing system at a cost of $7,377.05 for the mitigation efforts and $7,

Castle Key Indemnity Homestead Hurricane and wind 12/3/2024 $64,889

After assessing the damage and the true scope of repairs, the public adjuster produced an estimate identifying $64,889.91 in covered damage to the dwelling.

Castle Key Indemnity Orlando Water damage 3/3/2025 $63,870

Specifically, the Insured, with assistance from their public adjuster, submitted an estimate for $63,870.70, which is a fair and reasonable assessment for the repair/replacement of damages.

Castle Key Indemnity Tampa Hurricane and wind 12/12/2024 $62,149

To remedy and/or cure this CRN, Insurer must immediately tender payment in the amount of $ 62,149.00 less any applicable deductible and prior payment to the Insured to complete the repairs for the Insured property.

Castle Key Indemnity Boca Raton Water damage 3/4/2025 $58,651

Castle Key estimated the cost to return the property to its pre-loss condition in the amount of $11,871.23, before application of the deductible.

Castle Key Indemnity Groveland Hurricane and wind 12/16/2024 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED $50,618

Castle Key Indemnity Company also routinely refuses to pay claims in full when it has the ability to do so, waits to see if its insureds contest their coverage determination, as was necessary here, and, only then, will it capriciously invoke appraisal.

Castle Key Indemnity Kissimmee Water damage 10/1/2024 $48,038

Specifically, the Insureds, with assistance from their public adjuster, submitted an estimate for $48,038.21, which was a fair and reasonable assessment for the repair/replacement of damages.

Castle Key Indemnity Fort Pierce Hurricane and wind 11/22/2024 $45,463

Tender $42,963.46, representing the damages set forth in the estimate, less deductible, plus interest; 2.

Castle Key Indemnity Wesley Chapel Hurricane and wind 3/5/2025 $40,570

ON DECEMBER 11, 2024, THE INSURED OBTAINED A FINAL INVOICE FROM ROOFING BY PINNACLE, LLC, CONFIRMING THAT THE TOTAL COST OF NECESSARY REPAIRS WAS $40,570.55, THE SAME AMOUNT ORIGINALLY ESTIMATED BY CASTLE KEY.

Castle Key Indemnity Tampa 3/25/2025 $38,349

To remedy and/or cure this CRN, Insurer must immediately tender payment in the amount of $38,349.00 less any applicable deductible and prior payment to the Insured to complete the repairs for the Insured property.

Castle Key Indemnity Orlando Hurricane and wind 2/7/2025 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED $37,034

Castle Key Indemnity Company also routinely refuses to pay claims in full when it has the ability to do so, waits to see if its insureds contest their coverage determination, as was necessary here, and, only then, will it capriciously invoke appraisal.

Castle Key Indemnity Port St. Lucie Hurricane and wind 10/4/2024 $36,638

The Insured timely reported this damage to CASTLE KEY INDEMNITY COMPANY who assigned claim no. [redacted] to the loss that occurred.

Castle Key Indemnity Saint Johns Roof 2/21/2025 $33,450

Thereafter, an estimate was provided in the amount of $1,297.94, which was below the insured's deductible.

Castle Key Indemnity Orlando Hurricane and wind 12/19/2024 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED $33,072

Castle Key Indemnity Company also routinely refuses to pay claims in full when it has the ability to do so, waits to see if its insureds contest their coverage determination, as was necessary here, and, only then, will it capriciously invoke appraisal.

Castle Key Indemnity Orlando 1/7/2025 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED $25,464

Castle Key Indemnity Company also routinely refuses to pay claims in full when it has the ability to do so, waits to see if its insureds contest their coverage determination, as was necessary here, and, only then, will it capriciously invoke appraisal.

Castle Key Indemnity Oakland Park Business interruption 12/3/2024 $20,125

The Insured and Insured's representative provided the Insurance Company with all claim-related documents including an estimate to repair covered damages in the amount of $20,125.38 and other supporting documentation and/or information.

Castle Key Indemnity Royal Palm Beach 11/26/2024 $15,140

The insured provided the carrier with estimates as well as photographs of all the damages and an estimate in the amounts of $15,140.65 and $7,004.38.

Castle Key Indemnity Orange Park 12/9/2024 $1,806

To remedy and/or cure this CRN, Insurer must immediately tender payment in the amount of $1,806.96, less any applicable deductible and prior payment to the Insured, to complete the repairs for the Insured property.

Castle Key Indemnity 11/1/2024

To date, carrier has failed to issue the statutorily required coverage determination following the completed inspection and adjustment of the loss.

Castle Key Indemnity Deltona Hurricane and wind 11/26/2024

In order to cure this civil remedy notice, Castle Key must immediately tender $32,577.08 to "[name redacted] Godfrey and Cohen Law Group" less any prior payments and deductible.

Castle Key Indemnity Spring Hill Hurricane and wind 12/3/2024

Insurer failed to retain the experts needed to perform the inspection and needed to address the damage at issue and determine the repairs needed to restore the property.

Castle Key Indemnity Longwood Hurricane and wind 12/17/2024

CASTLE KEY can cure the violations contained herein by issuing a payment for all contractual damages owed, per estimates of $195,986.[address redacted]us interest, costs, and attorney's fees.

Castle Key Indemnity Sarasota Hurricane and wind 12/17/2024

CASTLE KEY can cure the violations contained herein by issuing a payment for all contractual damages owed, per estimates of $49,198.[address redacted]us interest, costs, and attorney's fees.

Castle Key Indemnity Tampa Business interruption 12/19/2024

Castle Key's handling and adjustment of the claim of loss reveals that it has failed to adopt or implement standards for the proper investigation of claims.

Castle Key Indemnity Lithia Hurricane and wind 12/20/2024

ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY (CASTLE KEY) HAS BEEN GIVEN COMPLETE ACCESS TO THE INSURED PROPERTY, HAS NOTICE OF THE CONDITION OF THE PROPERTY THROUGH THEIR OWN INSPECTION AND PHOTOGRAPHS.

Castle Key Indemnity Wesley Chapel Hurricane and wind 12/23/2024

CASTLE KEY can cure the violations contained herein by issuing a payment for all contractual damages owed, per estimates of $65,095.[address redacted]us interest, costs, and attorney's fees.

Castle Key Indemnity Wimauma 12/27/2024

To remedy this CRN, [name redacted] must immediately tender the full remaining amount of insurance benefits owed to the Insured for its services rendered in the amount of $26,041.43.

Castle Key Indemnity Lauderdale By The Sea Hurricane and wind 1/13/2025 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED

Additionally, neither this assessment nor any other supplemental damage resulting from this loss can be addressed as the three-year filing deadline from the date the hurricane made landfall has expired." This denial was wrong under the Policy since the "Loss Assessment" noted in the denial letter oc

Castle Key Indemnity The Villages 1/13/2025

At that time, we submitted a Letter of Representation (LOR) and a W-9, requesting a copy of the insured's policy jacket.

Castle Key Indemnity Leesburg Collapse and sinkhole 1/30/2025

It is not entirely clear what Castle Key's claim determination was because it has failed to issue a written coverage determination.

Castle Key Indemnity Wesley Chapel Hurricane and wind 2/6/2025

ADDITIONALLY, UPON INFORMATION AND BELIEF, THE CARRIER NOR THEIR THIRD-PARTY CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR PRODUCED ANY REPORT AND HAS ADMITTED IT HAS NOT RENDERED A COVERAGE DECISION.

Castle Key Indemnity Land O' Lakes Hurricane and wind 3/10/2025

The insurer failed to adopt proper standards of investigation and adjustment of losses or is otherwise not implementing those standards because the insurer is not acting with honesty and integrity.

Castle Key Indemnity Land O' Lakes Hurricane and wind 3/21/2025

CASTLE KEY HAS FAILED TO CREATE AND IMPLEMENT ADEQUATE GUIDELINES FOR THE PROPER INVESTIGATION, EVALUATION, AND HANDLING OF CLAIMS, LEADING TO SIGNIFICANT VIOLATIONS AS OUTLINED HEREIN.

Each row is a complaint filed by a policyholder against an insurer. The figure is the largest amount the filing names, usually an independent estimate of the repair. Nothing here is a finding by a court or by the Department.

Source: Florida Department of Financial Services, Civil Remedy Notices of Insurer Violations, reason Claim Denial. Names, addresses and claim numbers are removed. Search the whole archive →