HurricaneLaw.Pro, Florida and South Carolina property insurance claim resource HURRICANELAW.PRO
HOME / DENIALS / THE ARCHIVE
1,891 FILINGS · 191 INSURERS · PROPERTY CLAIMS ONLY

Find a denial like yours.

Every Florida property claim-denial filing we have read, searchable. Filter by insurer, by peril, by the argument the carrier ran. Each row quotes the filing and links to the state's public record.

Where can I look up Florida insurance claim denials?

Florida publishes every Civil Remedy Notice, the formal complaint a policyholder files against an insurer before suing for bad faith. We read 1,891 of them over denied property claims and put them in one searchable list: who the insurer was, what the claim was for, the repair figure the filing names, the arguments described, and a link to the filing itself.

Filings in the archive 1,891, naming 191 insurers
Window Accepted September 2024 to June 2025
Median repair figure named $76,344
Later withdrawn or resolved 187, where the carrier fixed it inside 60 days
What these are Allegations by policyholders, not findings by a court

Each row is one Florida Civil Remedy Notice. The guide covers what a notice must contain, how it is filed with DFS and the 60 days the insurer has to cure.

50 of 1,891 filings · largest figure first
Westchester Surplus Lines Saint Petersburg Hurricane and wind 11/13/2024 $18,250,563

The insureds utilized the services of a licensed public adjuster who inspected the insureds' property and determined that the loss was a covered loss and had caused $ $18,250,563.43 in damages before the deductible.

American Coastal Venice Hurricane and wind 2/20/2025 $16,753,564

The Carrier valued the claim at $517,994.13 less recoverable depreciation and deductible, which lead to an Actual Cash Value of $48,396.80.

Heritage Property & Casualty Port Charlotte Hurricane and wind 1/30/2025 $12,010,411

Per the attached (2) estimates as outlined by Storm Force Roofing, a supplemental check in the amount of $590,574.51 will be sent under separate cover.

American Coastal Bokeelia Hurricane and wind 9/13/2024 $10,644,844

On December 15, 2022, AmCoastal issued a $100,000 advance on the Claim.

Heritage Property & Casualty Fort Myers Hurricane and wind 1/27/2025 $8,638,026

THE ESTIMATED COST OF REPAIRS TO THE INSURED PROPERTY CURRENTLY STANDS AT APPROXIMATELY $ 8,638,026.43.

Everest Indemnity Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

Geovera Specialty Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

Indian Harbor Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

Ms Transverse Specialty Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

National Fire & Marine Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

Old Republic Union Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

Spinnaker Specialty Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

Underwriters at Lloyd's, London Winter Haven Hurricane and wind 1/15/2025 $7,666,005

To cure the circumstances giving rise to the violations described in this notice, the Insurers must promptly tender $8,069,040.94 to [name redacted] minus the applicable deductible and prior payments.

American Coastal West Melbourne Water damage 9/17/2024 $7,119,446

Didion's estimate is $2,908,503.89, less the $10,000.00 policy deductible, recoverable depreciation in the amount of $648,327.21, and items which fall under Ordinance or Law Coverage in the amount of $132,306.72.

Velocity Specialty Daytona Beach Hurricane and wind 9/25/2024 $6,328,000

The Policy provides coverage on a replacement cost basis with a limit of liability in the amount of $6,328,000 for building, $72,[address redacted]ructures, $345,000 for contents and $1,200,000 for business income coverage, subject to a 3% deductible ($238,250).

Heritage Property & Casualty Port Charlotte Hurricane and wind 10/8/2024 $5,693,298

The Insured's total damage is estimated by Strategic Claims Consultants at $5,584,523.87 ACV / $5,693,298.15 RCV.

Cypress Property & Casualty Punta Gorda Hurricane and wind 10/4/2024 $5,189,895

Cypress performed an initial evaluation of the claim and on December 19, 2022, issued an initial payment for undisputed damages for $57,331.85 ($453,802.85 minus deductible and depreciation).

Peleus Panama City Beach Hurricane and wind 3/13/2025 $4,700,000

The hurricane caused catastrophic damages to the roofs, windows, doors, exteriors, interiors, and numerous other building components and structures throughout the Property, resulting in more than $40,000,000 in damages.

American Coastal Daytona Beach Hurricane and wind 9/30/2024 $4,648,310

American Coastal has failed and/or refused to thoroughly, accurately, and completely investigate and evaluate the Insured's insurance claim for damages.

Velocity Specialty North Port Hurricane and wind 9/3/2024 $4,242,292

Insurers must also tender the full remaining contractual amount owed based on Foundations' estimate of $4,242,292.00, less any prior payments and applicable deductibles, subject to the terms of the policy.

Old Republic Union Placida Hurricane and wind 11/6/2024 $4,220,378

After drafting two estimates, the larger of which totaling $1,511,123.24 and deducting the deductible and depreciation, Insurers have paid a total of $926,483.26 for the substantial loss.

Heritage Property & Casualty Punta Gorda Hurricane and wind 12/6/2024 $4,193,153

On or about May 3rd, 2023 Insurer respond to the notice and provided Association a Statement of Loss, Loss Letter, and Building estimates in a letter for an amount of $4,193,153 before considering recoverable, non-recoverable, and deductible amounts.

American Coastal Lauderhill Hurricane and wind 6/5/2025 $3,950,000

American Coastal decided to accept the risk, write coverage and accepted a premium of $786,334.00.

Frontline Unlimited Miami Hurricane and wind 9/28/2024 $3,863,299

The insurer failed to make a claims determination within the prescribed statutory deadline and when the carrier did make payment, the claim payment was woefully deficient.

Frontline Unlimited North Port Hurricane and wind 10/8/2024 $3,752,009

Based on its field adjuster's estimate, FRONTLINE issued payment totaling $89,978.19, after the application of the deductible and recoverable depreciation.

Axis Surplus St. Petersburg Hurricane and wind 3/5/2025 $3,664,392

Having conducted thorough investigations and analysis, DAC prepared an estimate of costs to repair the damaged property in the amount of RCV $3,664,392.86.

Axis Surplus St. Petersburg Hurricane and wind 3/5/2025 $3,664,392

Having conducted thorough investigations and analysis, DAC prepared an estimate of costs to repair the damaged property in the amount of RCV $3,664,392.86.

Heritage Property & Casualty Punta Gorda Hurricane and wind 12/19/2024 $3,624,216

The Policy provides coverage on a replacement cost basis, subject to a 3% hurricane deductible, with a limit of liability in the amount of $770,000 for each building identified as Location # 1- Structure # 1-3, 7-8, 12, 13, and 16-18; and $376,000 for each building identified as Location # 1- Struct

Everest National West Palm Beach Business interruption 2/21/2025 $3,513,876

Insurer alleged, after retaining an engineer and Young & Associates, that the damages did not exceed the deductible and were only short of $7,000.

Frontline Unlimited Fort Myers Hurricane and wind 3/17/2025 $3,429,926

The insured demands the full value of the covered loss as detailed in the sworn statement in proof of loss: $3,429,926.88.

Centauri Specialty Longwood Hurricane and wind 10/21/2024 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED $3,426,647

Finally, on October 15, 2025 Centauri was forced to issue payment to Insured in the amount of $2,582,294,48 after application of the deductible and withholding recoverable depreciation.

Steadfast Clearwater Hurricane and wind 9/13/2024 $3,300,237

Subsequently, the insureds prepared a loss package in the amount of $3,300,237.50 needed to restore the property back to its pre-loss condition.

Southern-Owners 10/7/2024 $3,215,233

As a result of [name redacted] 's improper and defective work, Mr. [name redacted] suffered $3,215,233.64 in damages, including a significant amount of resulting property damage.

Heritage Property & Casualty Bonita Springs Hurricane and wind 9/24/2024 $3,045,606

Our email included supporting claim documentation for several necessary incurred mitigation and clean up expenses totaling $138,950.33, along with GlobalPro's estimate totaling $3,045,606.

American Coastal Naples Hurricane and wind 9/16/2024 $2,939,603

American Coastal has failed to create and implement adequate guidelines for the proper investigation and evaluation of claims, claims handling, and for training and supervision of employees resulting in statutory violations as set forth above.

Frontline Unlimited Ft. Myers Hurricane and wind 9/30/2024 $2,827,590

After its initial inspection, Frontline issued payments of only $688,920.51 for the main building, which failed to include any interior damage, and $61,445.16 for building 2.

Safepoint Cape Coral Hurricane and wind 10/23/2024 $2,209,750

The insurer failed to make a claims determination within the prescribed statutory deadline and when the carrier did make payment.

American Coastal Clermont Hurricane and wind 6/4/2025 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED $2,205,665

Upon reporting the loss, the Carrier denied the claim and failed to issue payment to Insured.

American Coastal Fort Myers Beach Hurricane and wind 12/17/2024 $2,127,929

As of October 24th, 2024 the Insurer had failed to pay or provide satisfactory explanation as to the $2,127,929.80 shortfall for costs incurred and estimated to be incurred by the [name redacted] .

American Coastal Fort Myers Beach Hurricane and wind 12/17/2024 $2,127,929

As of October 24th, 2024 the Insurer had failed to pay or provide satisfactory explanation as to the $2,127,929.80 shortfall for costs incurred and estimated to be incurred by the [name redacted] .

Heritage Property & Casualty Fort Myers Hurricane and wind 2/24/2025 WITHDRAWN OR RESOLVED $2,062,162

Specifically, the Association through its adjuster has submitted a detailed damage analysis and photos establishing damage in the amount of $1,832,803.26 ACV/ $2,062,162.29 RCV and Heritage refused to tender payment beyond the initial payment of $29,515.15.

Cincinnati Grand Rapids Hurricane and wind 10/9/2024 $2,024,403

Despite receiving detailed reports from ESi, photographs, and a repair estimate of $1,039,854.66 in July 2023 for Coverage A (dwelling), which included the full replacement of the windows, the Insurer failed to properly reinspect the Property.

Westchester Surplus Lines Englewood Hurricane and wind 2/14/2025 $1,954,972

An estimate for repair of all damages with respect to [name redacted] 's claim was prepared on their behalf for $1,954,972.53 was sent to Chubb.

Frontline Unlimited Captiva Hurricane and wind 3/25/2025 $1,866,273

The Insured's damages are calculated as follows: $1,864,378.87 ACV for Building damage, less prior payments of $1,184,146.06, less the deductible of $60,000.00, for a total of $620,232.81 ACV due under building coverage.

Condo Owners Reciprocal Exchange Tallahassee Hurricane and wind 3/28/2025 $1,856,950

The Policy has an "All Other Perils Deductible" in the amount of $2,500.00 per building.

Frontline Unlimited Englewood Hurricane and wind 3/10/2025 $1,743,867

FRONTLINE has accepted coverage for this loss and has issued 16 checks to the Insured totaling $1,490,363.92.

First Protective Bonita Springs Hurricane and wind 3/25/2025 $1,720,828

On March 22, 2023, a partial denial letter was issued by FRONTLINE and advising of the payments made on the claim, specifically, a net amount of $164,203.79 (ACV), after the deductible of $19,140.00 and the prior payment of $4,842.35 was applied.

American Coastal New Port Richey Collapse and sinkhole 6/20/2025 $1,702,830

Essentially, ACIC misrepresented to [name redacted] that approximately $1,702,830 of necessary subsurface repairs were not covered under the insurance policy.

Heritage Property & Casualty Naples Hurricane and wind 5/19/2025 $1,691,554

As is set forth hereafter, among other wrongs, considering the vicissitudes experienced by the Insured, this carrier has failed and refused to thoroughly, accurately, and completely investigate, evaluate, and adjust the Insured's insurance claims for damages in good faith.

Westchester Surplus Lines Fort Myers Hurricane and wind 1/10/2025 $1,631,418

Limit of Insurance 1 1 $835,000 1 2 $830,000 1 3 $835,000 These coverages are subject to a 5% windstorm or hail deductible.

HOW TO READ A ROW

Each row is a complaint filed by a policyholder against an insurer. The figure is the largest amount the filing names, usually an independent estimate of the repair. Nothing here is a finding by a court or by the Department.

Property claims only: auto and personal-injury matters are excluded, and where one loss was filed several times the duplicates are collapsed. Names, addresses and claim numbers are removed. Source: Florida Department of Financial Services, Civil Remedy Notices of Insurer Violations, reason Claim Denial. DFS Civil Remedy search ↗

THE DATA · FLORIDA CIVIL REMEDY NOTICE ARCHIVE

1,891 filings accepted September 2024 to June 2025, naming 191 insurers. Download every row with the fields this page prints: data.json (JSON).