What can you do if Heritage Property & Casualty denies your claim?
Put your dispute to Heritage Property & Casualty in writing and keep a copy, with your policy number, claim number, dates and the denial or payment letter. If it stays unresolved, file a complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services (DFS), referencing NAIC #14407. Florida offers DFS mediation for many residential property claims before you sue.
| Claims phone | 855-415-7120 |
|---|---|
| NAIC number | 14407 |
| Regulator | Florida Department of Financial Services (DFS) |
| Complaint helpline | 1-877-693-5236 |
| Civil Remedy Notices naming this insurer | 53 of 1,891 |
What does the public record show about Heritage Property & Casualty?
- •Heritage Property & Casualty Insurance Company (NAIC #14407) is a Clearwater-based carrier writing homeowners in 16 states, including Florida and South Carolina, under public parent Heritage Insurance Holdings (NYSE: HRTG).
- •It carries a Demotech Financial Stability Rating of A' (A Prime), affirmed June 2026.
- •Claims are filed at 855-415-7120; confirm the current number at heritagepci.com before relying on it.
- •Heritage drew 1,788 residential claim-denial Civil Remedy Notices in the fifteen months after Ian, the public filings our archive draws on; three real Heritage letters are on file.
What Heritage Property & Casualty policyholders report, and where to push back
General patterns reported on this type of claim, not specific findings about Heritage Property & Casualty. Every claim turns on its own policy and facts.
Heritage Property & Casualty, common questions
Who owns Heritage Property & Casualty?
Heritage Property & Casualty Insurance Company (NAIC #14407) is owned by Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc., a public company traded as HRTG, headquartered in Clearwater, Florida. Founded in 2012, it writes personal residential coverage in 16 states, including Florida and South Carolina. Your claim is handled by, and paid from, Heritage Property & Casualty Insurance Company.
How do I report or dispute a Heritage claim?
File a claim at 855-415-7120 or through heritagepci.com/claims-center; confirm the current number on their site. To dispute a decision, request the full claim file and the specific policy basis in writing. Florida offers free DFS mediation for residential claims and most policies include appraisal; South Carolina disputes run through the SC DOI consumer complaint process and S.C. Code 38-59. In Florida you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to give notice and 18 months for supplemental claims (Fla. Stat. 627.70132); South Carolina's contract limitation is 3 years. Confirm your dates with counsel.
Deal with Heritage Property & Casualty, and push back
Their official links, how to file a complaint with the state, and where to take the fight if a claim was denied or underpaid.
Official Heritage Property & Casualty pages, for reference. Confirm phone numbers and claim steps on the carrier’s own site.
- Gather your policy number, claim number, and dates, plus the denial or payment letter.
- Put your dispute to Heritage Property & Casualty in writing and keep a copy.
- Unresolved? File a complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services (DFS), referencing NAIC #14407.
- Florida offers DFS mediation for many residential property claims before you sue.
- If it’s a coverage or bad-faith dispute (not just a number), a property-insurance attorney can review it free.
Civil Remedy Notices naming Heritage Property & Casualty
Heritage Property & Casualty denials in the public file
- LETTER QUOTED IN A FILINGHeritage: 43 creased shingle tabs counted, then denied on the wrong date of loss →
- LETTER QUOTED IN A FILINGHeritage: an Ian claim closed on wear and tear, faulty construction and maintenance →
- LETTER QUOTED IN A FILINGHeritage: late notice, and an investigation the carrier says was prejudiced →
- LETTER QUOTED IN A FILINGHeritage: no prompt notice of Irma damage, and no factual information at all →
- LETTER QUOTED IN A FILINGHeritage: no storm-created opening inside, no evidence of wind outside →
- LETTER QUOTED IN A FILINGHeritage: the arithmetic of a below-deductible denial, line by line →
- LETTER QUOTED IN A FILINGHeritage: wind-driven rain found, storm-created opening not found →
- REGULATOR COMPLAINT · HURRICANE IAN (2022)Heritage: the supplemental payment that never came →
- REGULATOR COMPLAINTHeritage: coverage found, claim valued at $18,000, and no payment issued →
- CONSUMER COMPLAINTHeritage: water claim denied on a Water Damage Exclusion added at renewal for $99 →
Not legal advice, and not affiliated with or endorsed by Heritage Property & Casualty Insurance Company. Facts compiled from public records (NAIC, state regulators, the carrier) and current as of July 2026; company contacts and figures change, confirm against the carrier’s own site.
Heritage Property & Casualty claim denied or underpaid?
Upload the denial letter or estimate and your declarations page. A property-insurance attorney reviews it and tells you where you stand, free, no obligation.